assignment
  databases summary
   

Evaluating Information

Here is a set of criteria you can use when evaluating various sources of information:

CRITERIA FOR EVALUATING INFORMATION
Criteria Books, Magazine & Newspaper Articles Web sites
Relevant

Is the information related to your research topic?

Does the information address some aspect of your research question?

Is the information connected to your research topic?
Authoritative

Is the author's name frequently mentioned in your research?

Does the author have expertise in the subject area he/she is writing about?

Is there an author listed? (if not, be cautious!)

Is the information written by a well-established organization?

Reliable

Is the information supported with sufficient evidence?

Is this evidence included in a Works Cited list at the end of the book or article?

Is the information supported with sufficient evidence?

Is this evidence documented somewhere on the page?

How does the URL (web address) end? Check the end of the URL -- websites that end in ".gov" (government) or ".edu (educational) are generally more reliable than websites that end in ".com" (commercial).

Current

Information recently written or revised is generally more accurate than material that is out of date, so determine:

Is the information up to date?

When was it written? (check the year of publication).

Is the information up to date?

Can you find a "last updated" or "last modified" date at the bottom of the page?

If you don't know when the information was written, you need to be careful! It may be either inaccurate or out of date.


 
©2005-2010 Seneca Libraries, Seneca College of Applied Arts & Technology. All rights reserved.